How to Check a Forex Manager’s Track Record (Step by Step)

Short answer: To check a forex manager's track record, first confirm their registration with the regulator (in the US, NFA BASIC for commodity trading advisors and commodity pool operators), then compare the returns they show you with an independent, broker-linked record, and ask whether those returns are net of all fees. Look at the largest drawdowns and how long the record runs, not only the total gain; a third-party "verified" label does not show that the manager is registered or that results will continue.

This guide is educational and is not financial advice. ForexFunds.com does not verify, recommend or rank any manager. See our disclaimer. ForexFunds.com publishes this guide and is accountable for it; see how we research.

The short answer: a 5-step check

  1. Confirm registration with the regulator where the manager does business.
  2. Get the manager's written performance record and read it.
  3. Ask whether returns are net of all fees.
  4. Read the risk, not only the return: drawdowns and record length.
  5. Check any third-party tracker and understand what its "verified" label covers.

For a metric-by-metric inventory of what a complete record contains, see what a forex manager's track record should include. This page is the step-by-step check. For how the account itself works, see managed forex accounts.

Step 1: Confirm registration

United States. A commodity trading advisor (CTA) is an individual or organization that, for compensation or profit, advises others on buying or selling futures, commodity options, retail off-exchange forex contracts or swaps. A commodity pool operator (CPO) operates a pool that combines money from a number of people to trade those instruments and solicits funds for it. Depending on its activity, a firm must register unless it qualifies for an exemption or exclusion, and registration is handled by the National Futures Association (NFA) [S1]. NFA's BASIC is a free tool for researching the background of derivatives industry professionals [S2]. Search the firm name and each individual you deal with. For more on the role, see what a forex trading advisor (manager) is.

NFA also suggests searching FINRA's BrokerCheck for securities licences [S2]. For US securities brokers and advisers, FINRA BrokerCheck (brokercheck.finra.org) [S3] lets you search by name.

How to look a manager up on NFA BASIC

  1. Find BASIC yourself. Go to the NFA's website and open BASIC from there, not from a link the manager sends you.
  2. Search the firm first. Type the firm's legal name exactly as it appears on the advisory agreement. If you have the firm's NFA ID, search by that instead; it avoids mix-ups between firms with similar names.
  3. Then search each person. Search the trader and anyone who contacts you. Individuals who solicit business for a registered firm are usually listed as associated persons (APs) of that firm, so check that the person is linked to the firm on your agreement.
  4. Read the registration and membership. Check which categories the firm holds (for a forex manager, commodity trading advisor; for a fund, commodity pool operator), whether each is current rather than withdrawn or pending, and whether the firm is an NFA member.
  5. Read the history. Open any regulatory actions, arbitration cases or complaints listed for the firm and its people, and note the dates and outcomes.

The exact labels on BASIC may differ from the words used here. If you find nothing, try the firm's other names and spellings. If the firm is still not listed, ask why: it may be based outside the US, so check its home regulator's register, or it may claim an exemption, so ask for the exact rule in writing. For the US registration rule for forex advisors, see what a forex trading advisor (CTA) is.

United Kingdom. The FCA's Financial Services Register is a public record of firms, individuals and other bodies that are, or have been, authorised by the FCA or the PRA [S4]. Some firms appear as appointed representatives, which carry out activities on behalf of a principal firm; the FCA suggests checking with the principal what activities the representative is permitted to carry out [S4].

Australia. ASIC's Professional Registers search lets you find a person or organisation registered or licensed with ASIC to provide a service; ASIC advises checking what they are licensed to do, such as provide advice or offer investments. Its financial advisers register shows where an adviser has worked and the products they can advise on [S5].

Elsewhere, use the official register of the regulator in the manager's jurisdiction, and make sure the name, address and registration number match the entity that will hold your agreement.

Step 2: Get the manager's written performance record

Ask the manager for a written record of past performance. Check whether it names the trading program, says when the manager and the program began trading, shows monthly returns and drawdowns, and states how current the figures are. If any of these is missing, ask why.

A well-organized record also names the trader and where they are based, the regulator that oversees them, the broker that holds client accounts and where that broker is located, and the money under management (assets under management, or AUM) month by month, next to the largest peak-to-trough drawdown. You should be able to find each of these in a few minutes. If you have to dig for them, ask for a clearer version.

Step 3: Ask whether returns are net of all fees

Ask the manager whether the returns shown are net of all fees and expenses, including management and performance fees. When you compare a headline number with any other record, make sure both are calculated the same way.

Step 4: Read the risk, not only the return

A total gain says nothing about the path. Look at the largest drawdowns (how deep the losses went and how long recovery took) and at how many years the record covers; a short record has been through fewer market conditions (see investing in emerging forex traders). We do not suggest a "good" drawdown or Sharpe ratio threshold. For the measures themselves, see drawdowns explained, the Sharpe ratio and standard deviation.

Step 5: Check third-party trackers, and what "verified" means

Some third-party trackers label accounts as "verified". Read the tracker's own help pages to see exactly what its label checks. A broker-connection check does not tell you whether the manager is registered with a regulator, whether the account holds client money, or what will happen next, so use it alongside Steps 1 to 4.

A common-sense test: is the record plausible?

Before going further, ask whether the record makes sense. Compare it with long-running programs whose results are audited. A record that sits far above them, or that is far smoother than them with almost no losing months, deserves harder questions, not excitement. Claims of steady returns of 20% or more every month are a reason for extra caution. Never accept a record on the strength of its headline number; Steps 1 and 5 show how to check what stands behind it.

The record is not the only thing that matters

A good record is necessary but not enough. A few strong months can come from luck; a record that covers rising, falling and flat markets says more about skill. Read the manager's disclosure document for its market approach and trading style, and ask whether that style could keep working as the money under management grows. Past performance does not guarantee future results, so weigh the record together with the manager's registration, the fees and how your account is held.

Hypothetical, simulated and backtested results

Ask whether any results shown are hypothetical, simulated or backtested rather than from real client accounts. Modeled results like these are not a record of actual trading. When you evaluate performance, keep them separately identified from actual results, examine the assumptions behind them, including fees and slippage, and never treat them as returns that were actually achieved. NFA's interpretive notice on promotional material addresses the limitations of hypothetical results [S7].

What a complete track record looks like

The layout below is a made-up example with no real manager behind it. It shows where each item from the checklist should appear, so you can see at a glance what is missing from a record you are given.

ItemExample entry
Program and start dateExample FX Program; client trading since January 2019
Trader and firmJ. Example, Example Capital LLC, New York
Regulator and IDRegistered commodity trading advisor; NFA ID 0000000
Where client money is heldAccounts in each client's name at a named US futures commission merchant or retail foreign exchange dealer
Monthly returnsOne row per month since the start, net of all fees, for example Jan +1.2%, Feb −0.8%, Mar +0.4%
Money under managementMonth-end total for each month, for example $12.4 million
Worst drawdownLargest peak-to-low fall and how long recovery took, for example −9.6%, recovered in 7 months
Basis of the figuresActual client accounts; any hypothetical results shown separately and labelled
Prepared and checked byWho prepared the figures and whether an independent party reviewed them against account statements
Date of the figuresFigures through the end of last month

For a metric-by-metric list, see what a forex manager's track record should include.

A 10-point due-diligence checklist

Work through these before you sign anything. You can also download the checklist as a one-page PDF to print and fill in.

#CheckWhere to look
1The firm and each person you deal with are registered, or you know the exact exemption they rely onNFA BASIC in the US; the FCA or ASIC register elsewhere
2Your money goes into an account in your own name at a regulated broker or dealer, not to the managerAccount-opening papers; the broker's own statements
3You received the disclosure document before signingThe manager; read it before the advisory agreement, starting with the six things to read first
4The program, start date and length of the record are statedManager's written performance record
5Monthly returns and drawdowns are shown, month by monthManager's written performance record
6Returns are stated net of all fees and expensesAsk the manager in writing
7Trader, regulator, broker and money under management are namedManager's written performance record
8Hypothetical or simulated results are labelled and kept apart from actual resultsMarketing material and the record itself
9You know what any third-party "verified" label actually checksThe tracker's own help pages
10The record looks plausible next to long-running audited programsYour own comparison

Regulator pages worth reading before you sign: the CFTC's forex fraud advisory [S8], its eight things to know before trading forex [S9], and the NFA's investor best practices [S10].

Common questions

How do I verify a forex trader's track record?

Confirm registration first, then match the manager's monthly returns and drawdowns against an independent, broker-linked record, and ask whether returns are net of all fees. Follow the five steps above.

How do I check if a forex manager is registered with the NFA?

Search the firm and individual names in NFA BASIC, a free tool for researching derivatives industry professionals [S2].

Is a Myfxbook verified track record trustworthy?

Read Myfxbook's own help pages for what its verification checks. A broker-linked history is not a registration check, so still complete Step 1.

What should a forex track record include?

It should show the program, when trading began, monthly returns, drawdowns and how current the figures are. See our full inventory.

Is the track record the only thing that matters?

No. Weigh it with the manager's registration, trading style, fees and how the account is held. A long record across different market conditions says more than a few strong months.

What is the difference between hypothetical and actual performance?

Hypothetical results come from a model or backtest, not real accounts, so they are not a record of actual trading.

Are forex account managers regulated in the US?

Advising others for compensation on retail off-exchange forex is part of the CTA definition, and registration is required unless an exemption or exclusion applies [S1].

Sources

Dates are when each page was last checked.

Ask a question about managed forex accounts

FOREXFUNDS.COM

Leave us your email address for more information.

Formspree processes this submission for ForexFunds.com. See our Privacy Policy for details.